For decades, the criminal legal system and the public imagination have constructed intimate partner violence around visible markers: the emergency 911 dispatch, shattered property, or acute physical injury. Yet for countless women, Two-Spirit, trans, non-binary, and gender diverse individuals who turn to shelters and community legal clinics across our communities, abuse rarely begins with physical force. It operates through the everyday architecture of an invisible cage—where an abusive partner systematically micro-manages finances, monitors mobile devices, polices social connections, leverages immigration status, or uses quiet intimidation to strip away a person’s autonomy. When a survivor sits across from an intake worker and explains, "He never laid a hand on me, but I have no control over my life," our legal frameworks have historically offered little relief.
The passage of Bill C-16, the Protecting Victims Act, represents an ambitious attempt by Parliament to bridge that gap by codifying cumulative patterns of power, entrapment, and domination into the Canadian Criminal Code. Recently, YWCA Toronto hosted a sector-wide webinar bringing together community advocates, frontline shelter workers, anti-violence organizers, and legal practitioners to look critically beyond the legislative text. I had the privilege of moderating a candid dialogue with two exceptional sector leaders: Kat Owens, Legal Director at the Women’s Legal Education and Action Fund (LEAF), and Hoori Hamboyan, Senior Policy Advisor at the Office of the Federal Ombudsperson for Victims of Crime (OFOVC).
Together, we examined the practical realities of these reforms and confronted the central question facing our sector: The stated intention of legal reform is always to advance societal safety and safeguard human dignity—but will these amendments genuinely protect marginalized survivors in the years ahead, or will they introduce new vectors of systemic harm?
A critical takeaway for advocates is that Bill C-16 operates on a staggered timeline. Several key measures came into effect on July 18, 2026. Frontline caseworkers and counsel do not have to wait to invoke modernized criminal harassment provisions, which now explicitly capture cyber-stalking, AirTags, and covert electronic surveillance. Crucially, Parliament moved criminal harassment to an objective standard: prosecutors assess whether a reasonable person in the victim’s circumstances would fear for their safety, removing the evidentiary burden from survivors whose trauma responses were previously weaponized against them. The law also immediately created offences targeting non-consensual sexually explicit deepfakes and strengthened statutory presumptions for courtroom testimonial aids like screens and support animals.
Behind the scenes, another vital shift reshapes practice: the notice period for defense applications to subpoena a survivor’s private counselling or medical records was expanded from seven to sixty days before trial. This extended window gives legal clinics and independent counsel meaningful time to contest intrusive fishing expeditions into therapeutic records. Meanwhile, Parliament established a two-year transition window before the standalone criminal offence of coercive control can be formally charged, allowing police services, Crown attorneys, and courts time to build specialized training and protocols.
Yet as our panelists emphasized, compiling longitudinal evidence of control demands meticulous digital safety planning so that gathering documentation does not provoke retaliation. More urgently, an intersectional feminist analysis requires us to confront the grave risk of juridogenic harm—harm caused directly by engagement with the legal system. When police lack comprehensive education on power dynamics, they routinely misinterpret reactive resistance as mutual aggression, resulting in survivors being wrongfully dual-charged. For Indigenous, Black, racialized, newcomer, 2SLGBTQIA+, and survivors with disabilities, pervasive systemic bias compounds this risk. An immigrant woman whose spouse threatens her status, or an Indigenous mother fearing child welfare intervention, can easily have her trauma-induced distress labeled by first responders as "combative." Furthermore, cross-court contradictions continue to trap mothers between conflicting criminal non-contact bail conditions and family court parenting orders.
The fundamental truth our sector must voice is that the Criminal Code cannot house a survivor, provide an emergency shelter bed, or fund legal aid certificates. Statutory change alone will not keep women and gender diverse people safe without sustained public investments in accessible transitional housing, fully funded independent legal representation, and mandatory, community-led judicial education. The true measure of Bill C-16 will not be found in parliamentary records; it will be measured in whether marginalized survivors finally find genuine autonomy, institutional dignity, and safety when they reach out for help.
--
Learn more about the Women’s Legal Education and Action Fund (LEAF).
Learn more about the Office of the Federal Ombudsperson of Victims of Crime (OFOVC).
Learn more about YWCA Toronto's Advocacy.
--
Resources for further learning:
Deepa Mattoo: New era of trauma-informed intakes: What Ahluwalia and Bill C-16 demand of legal professionals.
LEAF Position Paper: Criminalization of Coercive Control
LEAF and Barbra Schlifer Commemorative Clinic: Joint Submission on Bill C-16
LEAF Factsheet: Restorative and transformative justice in Ontario
OFOVC Submission to the Standing Senate Committee on Legal and Constitutional Affairs (LCJC) Bill C 16 (Protecting Victims Act
OFOVC: Fulfilling the Promises of the Canadian Victims Bill of Rights: 10-year Progress Report
--
If you or someone you know is experiencing gender-based or intimate partner violence, you are not alone.
Assaulted Women’s Helpline – Crisis Line: 416 863 0511
Victim Services Toronto – Crisis Line: 416 808 7066
Toronto Shelter and Support Services – Central Intake Line: 311
Women’s College Hospital Sexual Assault/Domestic Violence Care Centre:
- Open 24/7 at 76 Grenville Street, Toronto, ON, M5S 1B2
- Phone: 416 323 6040
Find more supports here: https://www.torontocentralhealthline.ca/listservices.aspx?id=10669